top of page

Why Open-World Games Often Fail

How To Make The Best Open-World Ever .

Read Time 9 minutes

The gaming industry is a vast and complex space, and one that has experienced tremendous growth in recent years. With the advent of new technology and the increasing popularity of video games, the industry has exploded, and new titles are released every month. As gamers, we are always on the lookout for the next big thing, a game that can immerse us in an entirely new world and provide hours of entertainment. However, with so many options available, it is easy to fall into the trap of blindly praising a game without giving much thought to its flaws.

Blind praise is a phenomenon that has become increasingly prevalent in the gaming community. It involves the uncritical adoration of a game, without any consideration of its shortcomings. Blind praise can be harmful to the industry, as it can lead to a lack of constructive criticism and stagnation in game development. Developers may feel that they do not need to improve their games if they are receiving widespread praise, which can ultimately lead to a decline in the quality of future releases. Additionally, it can lead to a toxic environment in which fans attack those who voice criticism, which can be discouraging for those who want to share their opinions.

However, blind praise is not the only issue in the gaming community. In recent years, there has been a growing trend towards excessive criticism, where fans will attack a game without providing any constructive feedback. This can be just as harmful as blind praise, as it can discourage developers from pursuing their vision and can create a hostile environment for fans who enjoy the game. It is essential to strike a balance between blind praise and excessive criticism to ensure that the industry continues to grow and evolve.

In this article, we will delve deeper into the issues with blindly praising games and how it can be harmful to the industry. We will also explore why criticism is essential for the gaming industry and how it can lead to better games in the future. Lastly, we will provide some tips on how to be a better listener and offer constructive feedback to developers. By the end of this article, we hope that readers will have a better understanding of the importance of constructive criticism and how it can help the gaming industry continue to thrive.


Social Share Button (3) (5).png
Social Share Button (3) (4) (1).png
Social Share Button (2) (3) (1).png

Beyond Mere Acceptance .

Blind praise is not limited to just individual fans; it can also be present in the media. Gaming media outlets may feel pressure to give positive reviews to maintain good relationships with game developers, secure access to exclusive content, or attract more readers. This pressure can lead to reviews that lack objectivity and fail to provide a balanced perspective on a game's strengths and weaknesses. Such reviews can mislead consumers, leading them to purchase games that they may not enjoy or find disappointing.

Another aspect of blind praise is the tendency to compare games only to their predecessors rather than evaluating them on their own merits. Fans may have a strong attachment to a particular franchise and may overlook the shortcomings of the latest installment, focusing instead on how it compares to previous entries in the series. This type of comparison can be problematic, as it can result in games receiving undue praise or criticism based on how they compare to previous titles, rather than their own quality.

Moreover, blind praise can discourage developers from taking risks and trying new things. If a developer is praised for a certain aspect of a game, such as its graphics or story, they may be less likely to experiment with new gameplay mechanics or take risks in other areas. This can lead to stagnation in game development, with games becoming formulaic and predictable.

Review Minor Image (7) (1).png

The dynamic and responsive world of GTA III is what keeps players hooked

Another issue with blind praise is that it can create a polarizing effect within the gaming community. When fans feel attacked for their opinions, they may become defensive and lash out at those who disagree with them. This can lead to an unhealthy environment where discussion and criticism are discouraged, and differing opinions are not tolerated.

Lastly, it is important to note that blind praise is not exclusive to the gaming industry. It can be present in any industry where people have emotional attachments or personal preferences. However, it is particularly prevalent in the gaming industry due to the strong emotional connections that people often have with their favorite games.


In conclusion, blind praise is a dangerous phenomenon that can have negative consequences for the gaming industry. It can lead to a lack of critical feedback, a culture of toxicity, misleading reviews, unfair comparisons, and stagnation in game development. It is essential for gamers, media outlets, and developers to be aware of the dangers of blind praise and to strive for objective and balanced evaluations of games. By doing so, we can ensure that the industry continues to grow and evolve, providing new and exciting experiences for gamers worldwide.

Problems, Issues And Everything In Between: Not Always Sunshine .

Another reason why criticism is important is that it allows for the growth and evolution of the industry. As technology advances, so do gamers' expectations. Without criticism, developers would not know how to meet these expectations, and the industry would become stagnant. However, through constructive feedback and criticism, developers can create new and innovative games that push the boundaries of what is possible.

In addition, criticism can also promote diversity and inclusivity in the gaming industry. By listening to feedback from diverse groups of gamers, developers can create games that are more inclusive and representative of different cultures and backgrounds. This, in turn, can help make the gaming industry a more welcoming and inclusive space for all players.

While some may argue that criticism can be discouraging for developers and may lead to a negative impact on their mental health, it is essential to note that constructive criticism is not the same as blind hatred or harassment. Constructive criticism provides specific feedback on what can be improved, while blind hatred or harassment is aimed at tearing down a developer's work and character. It is essential to encourage constructive criticism while simultaneously condemning toxic behavior.

Review Minor Image (8) (1).png

The singular world structure of Elden Ring is nothing short of magnificent

In addition, criticism helps to create a community of dedicated gamers who are passionate about improving the industry. When players provide constructive feedback, they become invested in the game's success and are more likely to continue playing and supporting the game. This sense of community can also lead to more significant opportunities for developers to engage with their audience, leading to a more meaningful relationship between developers and players.

Moreover, criticism can also foster a sense of community within the gaming industry. By engaging in meaningful conversations about games, players can connect with each other and share their experiences. Criticism can help spark discussions that lead to a deeper understanding and appreciation of the art of game development.


In conclusion, criticism is a crucial aspect of the gaming industry that helps promote growth, diversity, and inclusivity. It provides valuable feedback for developers, helps gamers make informed decisions, and can create a sense of community among players. While blind praise may seem harmless, it can be detrimental to the industry's development, leading to stagnation and a lack of innovation. Therefore, it is essential to encourage constructive criticism while simultaneously condemning toxic behavior.

The Solutions: Always Prefer Sooner Rather Than Later .

One of the most significant benefits of being a gamer is the opportunity to engage in discussions with other players about games we love. However, with discussions, there often comes disagreements. It is essential to understand that everyone has different preferences and opinions when it comes to gaming, and there is no right or wrong way to enjoy a game.

It is important to recognize that disagreements are not necessarily bad things. Instead, they can be an opportunity to learn from others and see games from different perspectives. Even if we do not agree with someone's opinion, we should respect their right to have it and try to understand their reasoning behind it.

It is also important to remember that criticism of a game is not a personal attack on someone's character. Criticisms can be made respectfully, and gamers should be willing to accept them as a part of healthy discussion. We should be able to distinguish between a criticism of a game and an attack on someone's character or identity.

Review Minor Image (9) (1).png

Assassin's Creed Valhalla entices for its otherwordly take on the nordic era

It can be easy to fall into the trap of thinking that our way of playing a game is the only "correct" way. However, this kind of thinking is not helpful and can prevent us from experiencing new ways to enjoy games. Being open-minded and willing to try new things can lead to discovering new favorite games or genres.

Furthermore, it is essential to recognize that everyone has different backgrounds, experiences, and preferences that shape their opinions. Therefore, we should avoid generalizing or stereotyping others based on their opinions about a game. It is important to approach discussions with an open mind and avoid making assumptions about others.

In conclusion, disagreements are a natural part of any discussion, and it is essential to recognize that everyone's opinion is valid when it comes to enjoying a game. We should approach discussions with respect, be open to new perspectives, and avoid making assumptions about others based on their opinions. By embracing these principles, we can foster a positive and inclusive gaming community where everyone feels welcome to express their opinions and enjoy games in their unique way.

A Probable Future: Shaping The Tomorrow, For The Better .

Needless to say, the future of open-world games looks promising, but there will most certainly always exist room for improvement and barriers to overcome. To me and many others, a major area of innovation would be the use of procedural generation and AI to create massive game worlds that are unique and dynamic without losing that trace of humane touch. For creators, artists, designers, etc. they can use AI to create more complex, believable and authentic game worlds with events that are more responsive to the player's actions in a fraction of the time it would normally take.

As you know, one major drawback of these ultra-massive games is the absurd amount of reused content that is likely to come out as a byproduct of their sheer size. While players may appreciate the seemingly endless explorable regions such as in the case of No Man's Sky, the lack of variety and polish can be a turn-off for many. To address this issue, developers need to focus on finding ways to create harmony between the vastness of their game worlds and diverse, unique content. This could be accomplished through a combination of hand-crafted content and procedural generation, ensuring that players always have something new and exciting to discover.

Also, it might sound horrible at first, but cutting out the boring parts is actually a lot more beneficial than one might think. By automating certain aspects of the development process through the usage of procedural generation, developers can instead spend their attention elsewhere, resulting in a net positive for both companies and players alike. This would basically mean more dynamic and interesting game worlds that are constantly changing and evolving.


Review Minor Image (10) (1).png


In addition to these developments, we can also expect to see more and more open-world games that blur the line between triple-A and Indie titles and experiences. With the rise of digital distribution platforms and crowdfunding, smaller indie studios have gained more visibility and resources to create ambitious open-world games with innovative mechanics and creative storytelling. On the other hand, larger publishers have started to adopt some of the practices and aesthetics of indie games, such as more diverse representation, unconventional gameplay, and experimental narrative structures.

Not to mention, the rise of user-generated content on these fronts will also play a significant role in shaping the future of open-world games. Already, there are several games that allow players to explore massive game worlds alongside their friends, and we can expect to see even more of them offering this kind of experience. Additionally, developers may find ways to make it easier for players to contribute their own content to the game world, allowing for a more collaborative and engaging experience for everyone involved.

Moreover, advancements in hardware and software technology will allow developers to create even more stunning and realistic game worlds. With the advent of virtual and augmented reality, we can expect to see open-world games that are even more immersive and interactive, allowing players to experience the game world in a way that was previously impossible.

Overall, the future of open-world games is exciting and full of possibilities. As technology continues to advance, we can expect to see games that are more immersive, dynamic, and realistic than ever before.

Final Thoughts: The Bigger They're In Size, The Farther They Go .

As we've seen, creating a great open-world game is no easy feat, for not only does it require a tactful balance of exploration, storytelling, and gameplay, but an unparalleled attention to detail in addition to a bunch of organized effort, which is arguably the hardest part of all. The willingness to go above and beyond for its players is what makes certain games unforgettable, and being able to take risks whenever necessary is key to succeed and reap the rewards where others will most likely give up and scale down. From the biggest to the smallest of them all, the only thing that matters is that they're made for us, the consumers, and not just for our wallets, and are able to provide an escape route from reality that is faithful to our needs and not only to garner financial gain.

In the past, open-world games used to be criticized for being severely lackluster, with players frequently feeling like when they were being fooled in a way, since the supposed 'open-world' served merely to act as a distraction from how short and boring the main path would actually be without so many of those twists and turns. However, recent years have seen a surge of innovation in the genre, making it so that spending entire weeks on end immersed in a single virtual world is no longer a distant/impossible dream.


With each new release comes a renewed opportunity for developers to break the mold, to offer players something fresh and exciting that they've never experienced before, and as technology continues to advance and game-makers start to take hold of the untamed potential of AI, we can only imagine what incredible experiences await us in the near future.

As for ourselves, the players, we should learn to never take these incredible virtual worlds for granted and should give developers the time and space they need to cook something truly extraordinary and unique at every announcement that comes around. This means being patient and understanding that quality takes time, even if for such we'd have to wait longer than we would like, for, when working to create a truly amazing experience, it's crucial that we support the developers' creative vision and allow them the freedom to spin the bottle in new and ever-more exciting directions.


Copy of Review Final Image (4).png

Written by: Caius | Date - 07/03/2023

Other Posts

Facebook social media share button 2
Twitter social media share button 2
Reddit social media share button 2

Release Thoughts: Cyberpunk 2077 - "A long way to redemption"

Remnant From The Ashes Review | Retro_Vision

The Tree Slayer, First Of His Name ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎

High On Life Review | Retro_Vision

Let The Interstellar Teabagging Begin ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎

In Nightmare Review | Retro_Vision

When The Fever Dream Takes Over ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎

bottom of page